“The Society” publishes an intellectually unsound Statement of Principles

The Society under the patronage of Saint Wilfred and Saint Hilda is the new ecclesial entity within the Church of England, designed to maintain full communion within itself and to strive for communion with the traditional Churches of East and West.

This week the Council of Bishops of The Society has published a Statement of Principles entitled “Communion and Catholicity in the Church of England”. I maintain that this document is intellectually flawed because on the one hand it defines what full communion is, which includes the celebration of the one Eucharist, proceeds to demonstrate how communion within the Church of England is incomplete because of the ordination of women priests and bishops and yet completely illogically maintains that The Society and the remainder of the Church of England are in fact still one Church.

A careful study of the Principles will show that the “ecumenical” relationship described in the document which now exists within the Church of England is hardly different from the relationship with other non-Anglican churches, many of which come from a similar Anglican tradition.

Most of the ecclesiological arguments for the oneness of the Church are indeed not even Anglican arguments but are taken from the documents of the Second Vatican Council and ARCIC.

I believe that this Statement of Principles demonstrates clearly that The Society in itself is an ecclesial body resembling a Church (it might even be argued that it is a Church in the same way as the Church of England always was). It has its own ecclesial structures with an episcopate, and fulfils the criteria for full communion which the bishops themselves have defined.

Maintaining that one is still part of a body which calls itself the “Church” of England is self-delusion. The Society is in everything but name already a Continuing Anglican Church, and if we needed proof of that, this document provides it.

The next set of Principles should perhaps examine what it is that prevents this new ecclesial entity from seeking full communion with those whose documents, theology, liturgy they share (the traditional Church of the West, made visible in the See of Peter). An organisation already exists which expresses this full communion and maintains the Anglican tradition which The Society’s bishops value, and that is the Ordinariate.

David Murphy

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to “The Society” publishes an intellectually unsound Statement of Principles

  1. Father David Waller says:

    I agree with your summary of the flaws in this document but the reality is that the Society is not able even to be an ecclesial body resembling a church or a continuing church because its bishops do not have jurisdiction and its members fall under the canonical jurisdiction of those with whom they are not in communion. That is its fatal compromise; it is the thing FiF always said it could not accept and is a concept incomprehensible to the great Churches of East and West. Unless that it resolved it is difficult to see how it can have an ecclesial relationship with anyone but itself.

  2. Rev22:17 says:

    David,

    You wrote: The next set of Principles should perhaps examine what it is that prevents this new ecclesial entity from seeking full communion with those whose documents, theology, liturgy they share (the traditional Church of the West, made visible in the See of Peter). An organisation already exists which expresses this full communion and maintains the Anglican tradition which The Society’s bishops value, and that is the Ordinariate.

    One barrier is quite obvious. To leave the Church of England and become part of another body, the Society would have to forfeit its use of church buildings held in trust for the Church of England by the Crown.

    Norm.

  3. Lauren says:

    Great post by the way

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s