Changes in Kitchener, Ontario and Rochester, New York

For about a year now Father Jason Catania, formerly of Mount Calvary, Baltimore, has been priest-in-charge of St Edmund, King and Martyr, Ordinariate Sodality in Kitchener, ON, whilst driving to Rochester, NY, every month to celebrate Mass on a supply priest basis for the long-orphaned Ordinariate Fellowship of St. Alban, a round trip of about 350 miles.

It was evident that this was not intended as a permanent solution, and although movement was in the air, it was a surprise that on November 30th the St. Edmund’s website announced “Please be advised that the 5:00 p.m. Sunday Mass is ‘suspended’ until further notice.” without any further explanation. Here is a photo from Fr. Catania’s last Mass in Kitchener:

fr catania last day in KitchenerA partial explanation for this ‘suspension’ of Mass so close to Christmas came today, when Fr. Jason Catania announced by eMail:

“To the Fellowship of St. Alban:

At the request of the Personal Ordinariate of the Chair of St. Peter, I have accepted appointment as regular supply priest for the Fellowship of St. Alban. While this decision was initially made by our outgoing Ordinary, Monsignor Jeffrey Steenson, it has been reaffirmed by Bishop-elect Steven Lopes. Once living accommodations in Rochester can be arranged, I plan start celebrating Mass weekly, at the very least, beginning Saturday, January 2.

In the time since I have been making monthly visits to St. Alban’s, I have come to believe that the community has considerable potential for growth. It is my hope that together we can work to build the fellowship, for the benefit of the Ordinariate as well as the wider Catholic community in Rochester. I hope to be able to report further developments soon, but in the meanwhile, please pray for the leadership of both the Ordinariate and the Diocese of Rochester, as well as for me as I make my transition back to ministry in the United States.

Wishing you a blessed celebration of Our Lord’s Nativity,

Fr. Jason Catania”

Thus it would seem that Father Jason will be celebrating Christmas in neither of the two communities and is to transfer to Rochester not as “priest-in-charge” but as “supply priest”, which would suggest that this move is also only of a temporary nature.

My personal comment:

I must admit to a certain dismay that in an Ordinariate with so many priests it is not possible to find permanent pastoring solutions for so many communities. As far as I know, apart from the two named communities, there is a large community of Hispanic Ordinarians in Flushing, NY, and a community of Mohawk Ordinarians in Tyendinaga Territory, Canada, without an Ordinariate pastor. In other groups the pastor is known to be in bad health.

The UK Ordinariate is also not without its problems of this kind. Hemel Hempstead was without a regular priest for well over a year, Birmingham has never had a priest as pastor.

One can only commend the stalwart laypeople, Gary Freeman in Kitchener, Andrew Jordan in Rochester, Ron Crane in Birmingham and others whose names are not known to me, who have kept these groups alive during difficult times.

In our Cycle of Prayer we continue to pray monthly for all Ordinariate communities without pastor.

David Murphy

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Changes in Kitchener, Ontario and Rochester, New York

  1. Viola F. Hayhurst says:

    …..again with many so dedicated Priests still vainly knocking at the door…. why are not their impediments relaxed for admission ? Such as their status as cradle, confirmed Catholics, leaving the church but always desiring to return back to its fold ?

  2. Alan H says:

    I’m an Anglican who hasn’t yet “swum the Tiber”, living near Birmingham but in another Anglican diocese. I’m baffled by the failure to ordain Ron Crane in the Ordinariate. He was a highly regarded priest in the Church of England, serving in Washwood Heath and Wylde Green.

    • Viola F. Hayhurst says:

      (slightly amended)

      Same issues on this side of the “Pond” in the United States when extremely competent Priests — some of whom have been involved for many years in Anglican and Roman Catholic unification — who expressing their interest immediately in joining the Ordinariate were not admitted to ordination for reasons which were not always understood.

  3. EPMS says:

    Before Fr Catania arrived in Kitchener, a local diocesan priest, formerly an Anglican, celebrated the Ordinariate Rite for the St Edmund’s Sodality every Sunday. So the last state of this group appears to be worse than the first. Meanwhile there are at least a dozen OCSP clergy without a group, engaged exclusively in military chaplaincy or diocesan ministry.

  4. Rev22:17 says:



    The see of the ordinariate canonically became vacant when Pope Francis accepted Msgr. Steenson’s resignation from the office of ordinary. As the “administrator” of the ordinariate, Msgr. Steenson’s authority is severely curtailed: he can make only temporary assignments in response to immediate needs, so the permanent appointment now must await the installation of the new ordinary in any case. This is directly parallel to the situation of the parish of St. Mary the Virgin in Arlington, Texas, which had to await the installation of the present Bishop of Fort Worth to move into the ordinariate because its previous diocesan pastor retired when that see was vacant a while ago — the administrator of the diocese could arrange for an ordinariate pastor to supply sacramental and liturgical ministry for the vacant parish, but he lacked the authority either to appoint a new pastor or to transfer the parish to the ordinariate, leaving that parish in limbo until the new bishop took office.

    With respect to the subject of distribution of clergy, one certainly hopes that clergy of all of the ordinariates would be willing to relocate to serve congregations that need them.


  5. EPMS says:

    Any updates on St Edmund’s? While St Alban’s, Rochester has managed in the past to keep up activity during its several interregnums, there has been nothing on the St Edmund’s website since the announcement that Sunday mass would be discontinued as of December 2015. Are members still worshipping together?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s